On August 31, Amazon published a public response to the Federal Trade Commission's lawsuit over Sponsored Ads pricing and auction mechanics, calling the case "misguided" and releasing bidding figures to counter the claim that advertisers were harmed.
Key facts
- Effective: The case is in litigation; Amazon filed its public rebuttal Aug. 31. Nothing about the auction itself has changed
- Who is affected: Sellers running Sponsored Products, especially those splitting budget between Amazon and their own store
- What to do: Nothing yet. Record your trailing-12-month CPC and ROAS baseline so you can measure any future change
What happened
The FTC alleges Amazon misled advertisers about how Sponsored Ads are priced and auctioned (we covered the FTC and 22 states filing earlier). Amazon's response argues the complaint runs over 150 pages yet cites no evidence of consumer price increases, and mentions consumers only a handful of times.
On the advertiser side, Amazon says average cost-per-click for Sponsored Products search ads stayed flat from 2019 through 2024 when adjusted for inflation, while conversion rates grew 24% from 2021 to 2025. It adds that average winning bids fell 50% from 2019 to 2025, roughly 92% of placed ads do not go to the highest bid, and that advertisers saved an estimated $8 billion-plus between 2021 and 2025 as a result. Amazon also confirms it has priced clicks with a generalized second-price auction since ads launched in 2006, noting the complaint itself calls that "the industry standard for decades."
What this means for independent store owners
The value here is not the verdict — it is the numbers Amazon disclosed to defend itself. They amount to an official admission that relevance outweighs bid price in Sponsored Products ranking. If 92% of placements do not go to the top bid, then bidding your way to the top has far less leverage than most sellers assume, and conversion rate, review quality and click-through — the relevance signals — are where the real gains are. If you run both Amazon ads and Google or Meta ads for your own store, this is also why bidding tactics do not transfer between them.
One caveat: every figure above comes from the defendant. None of it is independently verified, and the FTC's account is the opposite, so do not cite it as neutral fact. No change to your campaigns is warranted today. What is worth doing is writing down your trailing-12-month CPC and ROAS. If the case eventually forces Amazon to disclose more auction detail or change the mechanism, you will need a "before" number to judge the impact.