Cyrus Shepard, founder of Zyppy SEO, ran an opt-out experiment on his own site and estimates that Google's AI features (AI Overviews and AI Mode) delivered about 21% of its search clicks, Search Engine Journal reports.
Key facts
- Effective: Already done. Opted out Sept 1, opted back in Sept 29
- Who is affected: Content sites and stores that rely on Google organic traffic and are working to earn AI citations
- Action needed: Nothing urgent. Do not opt out of AI features; consider measuring your own share the same way
What happened
On Sept 1, Shepard used Search Console's generative AI control to exclude the site from Google's AI features, then opted back in on Sept 29. He compared the 28 days opted out with the following 28 days to limit the effect of ranking and query changes. Google counts AI clicks as ordinary clicks, so the AI share is an estimate. Before the test, AI features produced 500 to 1,000 impressions a day, about 10% of the site's Google impressions. Estimated CTR on those impressions was about 0.9% (range 0.7% to 1.1%) versus roughly 0.4% overall. The result: about 21% of clicks came from AI features, or 23% including a small lift on regular listings. Shepard calls it a directional yardstick, not a general rule.
What this means for independent store owners
Do not copy this number onto your own store. It is one site, the clicks are modeled from a before-and-after comparison rather than measured directly, and the site had already invested heavily in earning AI citations, so its share may run high. Still, three takeaways. First, impressions in AI answers clicked at a higher rate (about 0.9%) than the site's overall average (about 0.4%), so being cited is not just empty visibility. Second, pages that appeared in AI Overviews saw a slightly higher CTR on their regular listings too, a possible brand halo, though the effect was small and the cause is unproven. Third, there is no good reason to opt out to protect clicks. A practical step: record your current Search Console clicks and impressions as a baseline, make sure key pages such as product pages and buying guides carry clean structured data and quotable factual content, and only then consider running a similar comparison. Note that Google says exclusions can take several days to apply, which adds noise to any test like this.